Going Off-Grid Solar - NOT!


Bob Bruninga, WB4APR

If you have no access to the GRID,
this page is not for you!
You have no choice but to be off-grid.


But if you currently have access to the grid and are considering going off grid, please read this page. Staying on-grid can give you more than DOUBLE the power for less cost and avoid battery maintenance for the rest of your life. We all want to take advantage of the tremendous drop in solar panel cost and the significant economic advantage of owning our own power station (as shown to the right). This chart shows the 12:1 drop in panel prices over the last decades and 2:1 drop just last year. The chart also shows the world exponential growth in production of solar PV panels. The 2010 value of 14,000 MW is not even shown full scale on this chart!

Do not think the grid is your enemy! It is your economic lifesaver!

OFF-GRID Makes No Economic Sense Whatsoever! (as long as you have access to the grid). The reason is simple. Modern grid-tie solar systems get 100% efficient and nearly unlimited storage in the grid and require virtually no maintenance for life. On the other hand, Off-grid throws away 30% or more of all power in charging/discharging losses and throws away another 50% of your annual incoming solar power because the battery can't save the excess power in summer for use in the winter when you need it.

Why am I so anti-batteries?. . . Because I always thought you had to have batteries as part of any solar system, and there was simply no way I could make the numbers work out for home-solar to be economical (with-batteries). So I wasted several years with this totally incorrect assumption and am now getting into solar a few years later than when it became not only practical, but cost effective with grid-tie. I want to save you from making the wrong assumption too. Forget batteries! (if you have grid access)....

LESSON #1 never plan on putting energy into a battery if there is a way to use it immediately and directly. Putting it in a battery throws away 30% to 40% right off the top in charge and discharge inefficiencies. If you have access to the grid, it makes no economical sense to give that up! Energy storage in the grid is 100% efficient whereas storing energy in batteries not only throws away 30% of your energy, but also:

LESSON #2 it also throws away all the excess solar power once your batteries are fully charged on a good summer day and there is no way it can save that excess power for winter, even if you did have a bigger battery system. Your battery system has to be sized to hold a few days energy on the worst solar day of the year (December). But the solar power available then is as much as 1/3rd of what you will get in the summer.

LESSON #3 Even if you waste lots of money investing in 3 times the needed battery to be able to be sure to capture all the solar you can generate on a long summer day, you and your family must find a way to use all that extra power that night in order to have battery room for the next day's summer flood of excess solar power. The result is you simply waste excess summer solar power. There is no battery big enough to save that excess (double) summer solar power for the winter when you need it (hal or less). (Actually, there is, and it is called THE GRID)...

LESSON #4: With grid tie, you basically have an infinite capacity battery that can save summer excess power and give it back to you in the winter with 100% efficiency. Actually, it is not infinite, it is basically equal to your TOTAL Annual energy usage beacuse the power companies expect you to not bank up excess power longer than a year.

LESSON #5: There is no battery maintenance with Grid-Tie. With batteries, you are burdened with continuous maintenace and periodic battery replacement for the rest of your life!

Off grid is for when you have no choice: and must generate and store your own power... or it is cost prohibitive to run the grid to your house (now that most utilities pass that cost directly to the user...)... In those cases, Solar power with Battery storage is the only way to go! It is great. (But so much better if you have the grid!)

Giving up the grid if you already have it does not make ANY economical sense.

  • Avoid batteries unless you like wasting 30 to 40% of your solar power investment...
  • And throwing away all your summer excess power (more than half your average power!)...
  • And Only getting HALF your solar array power potential in the winter!
  • And messing with batteries the rest of your life...
  • And replacing the batteries every 5 years or so for the rest of your life.

    Emergency Backup Power: And don't even consider batteries for that 0.1% of the time when the grid goes out and you need backup power. For power backup in the rare blackout a few hours every year or the bad day or so every decade or so, simply use your car generator and an inverter. See some of this on my Prius Power web page.

    NET METERING: Of course, all the benefits of grid-tie solar depends on having NET METERING in your area. Meaning that all energy you put into the grid you can get back out at the same cost as putting it in. This is the case in most energy conscious states bylaw. It is a win-win for both the homeowner AND the utility company, so there is no chance it will ever go away.

    Off-grid battery systems are ideal for small remote electric transmitters and radio systems on mountain tops where the load is constant (and it is the only possible solution). But it makes no economic sense whatsoever in a place where there is access to the grid.

    Keep your grid! (if you have it). Yes, you will have a $10/month metering fee even if you use zero net power, but that is a trivial cost to pay to avoid messing with batteries for the rest of your life and replaceing them every 3 years, and losing 30% of all power you generate, and wasting half of your excess solar power in the summer.

    Hope this helps

    Bob, WB4APR

    Please see more on my Alternative Energy web page!
    and / or, take a look at my Solar Power PPT presentation


    The rest of this page has not yet been edited out and is just som old stuff on other pages.

    solar augmented Salvage Prius, And there is another page on using the Prius for emergency field power, See my nearly born-again (powerpoint) conversion to a Solar Junkie in August 2009!

    POLLUTING ALTERNATIVES: If you look carefully in the photo of my array at the top of this page, you will see the smokestacks of the 500 MegaWatt A.H. Wagner coal-fired generator plant just 4 miles down the creek. By my calculations, just my home alone consumes about 10 MegaWattHours (MWH) of electricity per year. I hope to generate my own solar 10 MWH to eliminate completely my share of the pollution from that plant which amounts to:

    22,000 lbs of Carbon Dioxide
    350 lbs of sulfur dioxide
    1 ounce of Uranium and Thorium
    .00004 ounce of Mercury

    All of this pollution that I am responsible for is falling on the nearby Chesapeake Bay and watershed and my creek. Yet, I want to eliminate my contribution to this pollution by installing my 8 kW clean-solar system which will just about break even by producing my own annual 10 MWH's of clean-renewable-energy. So, at my own expense, I am offering to clean up the Bay by having solar panels on my pier, but am blocked by an outdated and short-sighted law of the Maryland Department of the Environment who are charged with protecting not just the water under my pier, but the air above and the soil beneath.

    Plan-B Solar-in-Yard: 21 Dec 2010 - So, after 9 months and $2000 of fees, the MDE's denial of panels on piers still stands. So I designed the panels to sit on the only sunny part of my lawn down by the water.... Don't be fooled by the winter image above. My roof is more than 50% shaded throughout all times of the day and most months of the year. So we submitted for a building permit in September 2010 only to be immediately DISAPPROVED! Maryland does not allow anything to be built within 100' of the shoreline. So, with additional fees, I applied for a Variance. On 21 December 2010 I appeared before the Hearing Officer and presented my case. Here are some of the materials I used:

    .

    Environmental Benefits of Solar: The above two images show the pollution-elimmination impact of my solar project. Each 3'x5' panel eliminates about the same amount of pollutants in a year as about 8 mature trees remove in a year. This means my 42 panel array is equivalent to the environmental benefits of about 300 trees compared to coal. But even more telling is to look at not just the pollution impact of coal electricity, but also the sheer magnitude of environmental distruction.

    Unseen Impact of Coal Electricity: In the image to the far right are 4 tons of coal which is about the energy equivalent of the 10 MHhrs of energy our house requires per year. Not only do we energy-consuming-&-wasteful Americans not see this tonnage, we also do not see the 80 tons of trees, topsoil, habitat and dirt that has to be pushed off a mountain top in West Virginia and into the nearby valleys and streams just to get to that coal. This 80 tons of decimation of the environment PER YEAR for my one house is shown in the near image to the right which shows four 20 ton freight cars needed to move that debris. The next image below right is just one of the hundreds of mountains and habitat in West Virginia being destroyed for our coal energy addiction... Folks, this approach to our environment IS NOT SUSTAINABLE!

    Variance Issues: With the proponderance of benefits of my solar project in my front yard, the County did agree that the varance was appropriate, but with one big catch-22 provision. They requested that there be the standard mitigation for any variance in the 100' foot critical area buffer. This means that the disturbance in the buffer area (690 square feet) must be offset with 3-to-1 or 2000 square feet of new trees. In otherwords, I can have the solar panels, but I have to plant so many trees in compensation that my lawn becomes a forest and we are back to square-ONE, that is, no solar access!

    The Hearing Judge has 30 days to make a ruling. He did! In our favor! Now the building permit has been submitted and then we will probably have to do battle with their requiements for disturbance mitigation. We will see if sanity prevails.

    SOLAR PRIUS:

    My first alternative energy project was my Solar Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicle (PHEV) I built from a salvage Prius.. It had been totaled on the drivers side, but I just beat it out with a sledge hammer and coverd the bashed-in door with the white sign! This soon morphed into my Prius Field-Day Power project to combine high power solar, with thousands of watts of backup gasoline driven generator power in the Prius for providing emergency power for field operating events such as the annual Amateur Radio Field Day or Scouting events shown below.

    . .

    PRIUS POWER: The Prius is a power station on wheels. It has a 12 volt electrical system for normal car accessories, and a 220 Volt 7 Amp-Hour Battery for propulsion assistance, two 50 kW motor-generators, a 50 Kw DC/DC converter/inverter, and a 76 Hp gas engine all integrated into a seamless power system. See more on my Solar Plug-in Prius

    115 VAC Power: is provided by a 1200 Watt AC inverter running on the car's 12 volt power system (shown in the right photo above). This 1200 watts drawn from teh car's 12 volt system is augmented by the 100 Amp DC/DC converter from the car's propulsion batteries and generators.

    SOLAR-POWER: . Adding solar panels to the Prius not only provides free energy to offset the cost of gas a few percent, but also to provide an effective application for solar power in other places where you might need it. The solar panels shown here can provide as much as 215 peak Watts of power good for about 1.7 KWh of free electricity when parked for 8 hours in Arizona sun. (unfortunately, only 800 Wh in Maryland Sun). Solar Power portability gives peace-of-mind where there is no gas or plug-in electricity available. . (more on my Solar Prius)...


    When you can take solar power where you need it, then its value can be far greater than 15 cents per KWH and is cheap at any price. . Just consuming it in the Prius is an equivalent payback of 30 cents per KWH compared to the 15 cents at home. . Plus it reduces dependency on foreign oil! . A 1200 Watt AC inverter in the back (see photo above) provides plenty of AC power to go.

    Emergency Solar Power Trailer: I had a few extra low voltage solar panels so I put them on the solar trailer to the right. It contains about 300 watts of solar panels plus a deep cycle marine battery and 1200 Watt inverter. The top wood section of the trailer folds over to not only protect the solar panels during travel but to also hide them out of sight when parked or not in use. When closed, the top wood section looks like an open top trailer with about 6 inch sides. The false bottom conceals the nested solar panels.

    In addition, when open, the bottom set of panels are also hinged to give access to the battery and inverter below. Plus this area provides hidden storage for extra power cords, cables and accessories. (see picture)

    220 VDC POWER CONNECTORS: . One of the first issues with distributing 220 VDC power is finding a safe connector that is innexpensive and readily available yet, cannot be confused with any other electrical connector. . This connector must be unique to prevent anyone from plugging in any non 220 VDC device. . The connector we came up with was a standard two-prong power plug but with two PREVENTION devices to prevent inadvertant plugging in of other devices. The connector is shown above right.

    A standard two-prong socket is used, but without the usual 3rd ground pin. . This blocks the use of any 3 wire 115 VAC power cord. . In addition, a 3/16ths inch nylon protrusion is fixed to the center of this receptical inbetween the two prongs. . This blocks the use of any 2-wire 115 VAC devices. . To make a mating two prong plug, a standard replacement plug is used but the center is drilled out to pass this blocking pin as shown in the photo. . On the right, this center pin protrudes into an unused, and isolated area of the hard plastic plug construction. . These connectors cost under $2 each for both the plug and the receptical.

    Lightweight Power Cords: . Because of the much lower current demand at 220 VDC, a #18 zip cord can easily carry plenty of power over hundreds of feet. . In the photo to the right, the original 25 feet of large orange extension cord were removed and about 120 feet of #18 lamp cord will fit on this convenient spool system. . The current carrying capacity of #18 is as high as 10 amps, but I limit mine by fuses to only 5 Amps. . Again, the outlets are blocked from any inadvertant use by the uninformed by the dual protection-blocking system. . Only switching power supplies or other loads that can operate on 220 VDC are provided with these matching plugs.

    (YOUR MILEAGE MAY VARY!)...

    Bottom line: . The time is now to go solar! We cannot continue to send billions of dollars a day overseas to buy polluting oil for our energy needs when it is right there outside our door. Also think in terms of your total energy footprint and consider how to integrate your transpotrtation demands into your own home solar system and energy needs.

    Bob Bruninga, WB4APR,
    President APRS Engineering LLC